A Master Positioning dissection and a Marty Marion take-down of one of the most ridiculous but persistent sacred cows in marketing: Brand Archetypes. Read why Brand Archetypes are the modern-day equivalent of marketing and advertising snake-oil, and those who sell and teach Brand Archetypes need to be tarred, feathered, and run out of town on a rail.
Skeptical? Go Ahead, Ask Zoltar: What Sign Is My Brand? And Will It Find True Love?
If You Think You’re In Control Of Your Own Decisions, Think Again
Before anyone gets heated over this article, and let me promise you, more than a few serious marketers and self-anointed brand ‘experts’ have raked me over the coals for my perspective on this subject, a few words of background might be appropriate.
I have had what one might conservatively call an extraordinary career in marketing and advertising for more than 40 years. I have been a senior executive and principal of several of the world’s largest Madison Avenue ‘Mad Men’ elite advertising agencies. I have served as International Director of Strategic Planning for major global agencies.
I have been a strategic consultant to dozens of the largest brands on the planet, from Pfizer and P&G to AT&T, Universal Studios, Caesar’s Palace, and Rakuten and many more. I am a two-time Clio Award recipient and a Columbia University Executive MBA program graduate.
I have been teaching the leading courses on brand positioning science for more than 30 years. And I have just published my 350-page book, Advanced Brand Positioning and The De-Positioning Matrix™, by far the definitive playbook for unlocking unstoppable customer and client acquisition at scale.
[My book is available at masterpositioning.com]
I don’t say any of this to brag; simply to confirm that the opinions expressed in this article are based on decades of experience leading and creating the strategic planning, product launch and marketing, and customer acquisition programs for hundreds of billions of dollars in revenue for dozens of category-leading enterprise brands.
So let me start off by being as direct as I can possibly be.
BRAND ARCHETYPES ARE BULLSHIT.
Complete. Utter. Nonsense.
They don’t work, and they almost always lead brands to build marketing, advertising and communications strategies that are destined to fail. If your brand’s marketing platform is based on the methodology of Brand Archetypes, you have already lost, and you just don’t know it yet.
Yes, I know there are highly regarded brand strategists and marketing “experts” who swear by archetypes, and others who take the wishy-washy middle ground that “it’s a useful tool, but don’t bet the farm on it.” I’d love to get a list of their clients. Just sayin’.
If teaching Brand Archetypes is your primary business, you are the modern-day equivalent of a storefront fortune teller in my opinion. Saying “Your brand is the (fill in the blank) archetype, so your brand voice should be such and so” is the equivalent of telling a hapless lovelorn soul that “The love of your life is right around the corner. Now pay me.” Sorry, not sorry.
I find it disheartening, to be honest, that one of the hottest topics still being talked about and taught by many brand and branding “experts” is Brand Archetypes. And it is being gobbled up like M&Ms (just one of dozens of my former clients) by students of brand strategy, brand owners, and marketers. And why not? It is a profitable business. It is just one that does more potential harm than good.
Too many marketers, brand owners, brand strategy consultants and even top marketing agencies are overly obsessed with using “archetypes” to map the future of their brands and their clients’ brands. They use it to divine how to create the right “brand personas” and “brand stories,” to narrow down exactly the right “brand voice” to communicate a brand’s USP (another masterful piece of outdated trash I am going to destroy in a future article) for their ideal target customers.
Pick one of the sacred 12, light your incense, chant a little, and voila, your brand’s personality pops out of the ether, ready to promote and capture the dominant position in your category. Like an Easy-Bake Oven, but for brands.
Is there any value at all in brand archetypes? Sure. They can a decent (barely) starting point in a discussion of various traits your brand might aspire to or possess. But it stops there.
Here is the problem: it sounds awesome, it makes a very interesting story, the details of each of the 12 Brand Archetypes are intensely mapped out to the finest of details, and each one is ascribed a set of powerful attributes. But it just doesn’t work. And any resemblance to actual results is either accidental or placebo.
Brand Archetypes are a sham. In fact, they are downright dangerous.
Why Smart Marketers Fall for This Snake Oil
Before I get to where this nonsense actually came from, and why it is garbage dressed up as strategy, it is worth a minute on why so many otherwise capable marketers have fallen for it. The answer is not that they are dumb. The answer is that the Brand Archetype framework exploits several well-documented cognitive vulnerabilities at once, and it exploits them beautifully.
First, there is cognitive ease. Daniel Kahneman’s entire body of work on human judgment, the body of work that won him the Nobel Prize in Economics, boils down to one brutal observation: human beings prefer ideas that are easy to hold in the mind over ideas that are true but difficult.
A 12-box framework with colorful infographics and mythological labels is easy to hold in the mind. A rigorous Brand Positioning Platform built from target pain, competitive displacement, proof structure, and De-Positioning logic is not. Guess which one sells better in a two-hour workshop.
Second, there is authority bias. Jung is famous. Freud is famous. Tossing around “collective unconscious” at a strategy meeting sounds intellectually serious, even when the underlying claim doesn’t hold together. People mistake prestige for validity. Big mistake.
Third, there is representativeness bias and confirmation bias. If a brand looks like a “Hero” brand, people rush to classify it as one. Once they have classified it, they start selecting evidence that confirms the classification and ignoring evidence that doesn’t. That is not analysis. That is confirmation bias with a mood board attached.
Fourth, and maybe most important, there is the comfort of status quo bias. Samuelson and Zeckhauser’s foundational 1988 study on status quo bias showed that people disproportionately stick with current options, current frameworks, and current categories, even when better alternatives are available.
Once the archetype framework embedded itself into agency decks and MBA syllabi, it became the default. And defaults are sticky. That is exactly why bad ideas survive in this business far longer than they should.
So when you see archetypes being defended, you are not necessarily seeing strategy. You are usually seeing cognitive biases dressed up as sophistication. And I say this with full awareness of the irony, because the behavioral science that explains why marketers fall for archetypes is the same behavioral science that serious brand strategists use to engineer actual switching behavior in the real marketplace. More on that shortly.
So Where Does This Nonsense Come From?
If we are going to properly grill this sacred cow, we need to go back to the source, because as you have surely heard, “garbage in, garbage out.”
The theory of archetypes is generally attributed to the early work of Carl Jung: German psychologist, psychiatrist, self-admittedly completely insane nut-bar, and a huge supporter of the works of Sigmund Freud. Jung originally detailed what he believed were four primary archetypes that stemmed from the “collective human unconscious,” and that therefore supposedly control our behavior:
1. The “Self.” Jung used this to describe the experience of “unity within experience.” He saw the Self archetype as embodying the ultimate aim of every individual to achieve a state of self-actualization, to become what one can become. You know, “be all you can be.” Very Army recruiting poster.
2. The “Shadow.” Jung said the Shadow archetype represented the primal, animalistic side of our personality, and was the source of both our creative as well as our destructive behaviors. He believed it was borne from our need for safety and survival.
3. The “Animus.” Jung, who was always vying for popularity with the sexually obsessed Sigmund Freud, just had to have his own theory of sexualization-driven behavior. The Animus archetype represents the “other” side of our biological sex. Jung said that every male has feminine tendencies, and that every woman has masculine tendencies. Today, this is even a more nuanced discussion.
4. The “Persona.” This is the “mask” everyone wears to face the outside world. To Jung, everyone wants to be either more than they are, or different in the eyes of others, so they create a Persona to represent what they want others to think of them.
For a while, in the late 1940s to mid-1950s, the topic of archetypes was quite a popular subject. Jung and Freud were major names influencing almost every aspect of society, medicine, and the study of human psychology. They were always in the news and in the headlines.
But guess what else was a hugely popular and quickly evolving subject at the exact same time, focused almost entirely on the study (and control) of human psychology? Advertising.
See where this is going?
Never ones to let a marketing opportunity slip by, the marketers, advertisers, agencies and “marketing consultants” of the Golden Age of Advertising saw an amazing opportunity to capitalize on the hot topics of consumer psychology and archetypes. They expanded the original four, from our friend Jung, into 12. They refined them to define the personalities not of people, but of brands. And they sold this repackaged mythology back to clients for insane money. Did somebody say snake oil? And yes, mea maxima culpa. As a young acolyte in the halls of the elite Madison Ave ad agencies, I too contributed to perpetuating this garbage thinking I was actually helping our clients win their markets. But enough about me.
The 12-archetype version we know today was most prominently codified in Margaret Mark and Carol S. Pearson’s 2001 book The Hero and the Outlaw: Building Extraordinary Brands Through the Power of Archetypes.
That book is the bloodline. That is what people are buying into, whether they know it or not. It is also where the marketing industry stopped asking whether this framework actually predicts commercial performance and started treating it as doctrine.
Fast forward to today. Almost every marketer is aware that there are officially 12 Brand Archetypes (I am still not sure who exactly certified this as the correct or appropriate number, but we will get to that). Each one represents a unique personality, aspiration, and a set of characteristics that a brand can or does possess, and thus build a marketing and communications and advertising campaign around.
Sounds groovy, no?
Now Let’s Take a Look Inside Jung’s Asylum
While developing his original theory of archetypes (the “garbage in” part) that resulted in today’s 12 Brand Archetypes (the “garbage out” part), Jung can be quoted directly from his own book, The Archetypes and The Collective Unconscious, Volume 9, Part 1, 1954.
He said, and this is a direct quote, that he felt he was “living in an insane asylum of his own making, with all these fantastic figures: centaurs, nymphs, satyrs, gods, and goddesses as though they were patients, and I was analyzing them.”
So let’s stop here for a quick moment to recap.
The entire conceptual seed from which the modern Brand Archetype industry grew was planted in an imaginary insane asylum, built out of images primarily related to sexual obsession, and populated by nymphs, goddesses, centaurs, satyrs, alchemy, religious symbolism, and a deep belief in invisible spirits. Those aren’t my words. Those are Jung’s words. His asylum. His centaurs. His nymphs. His gods and goddesses.
Exactly the foundation to build a successful brand on, right? Exactly the evidentiary bedrock you want underneath a multimillion-dollar product launch. Exactly the rigorous commercial architecture you want guiding your customer acquisition strategy in a crowded category with aggressive competitors and finite consumer attention.
Let’s continue.
The 12 Brand Archetypes being taught today are not founded out of any scientific study or on the back of any rational scientific (or marketing) foundation. They are not the result of the work of dozens of the top marketing minds in the world, based on the case studies of hundreds of leading successful brands and the reactions and buying behaviors of tens of thousands or millions of consumers.
Archetypes were created in the mind of a disturbed hallucinator, obsessed with visions of sex, myths, alchemy, and religious symbolism. There is zero actual science, and (even more damning) zero marketing science, in the creation of the original four archetypes of Jung, or the 12 magical Brand Archetypes being hawked and taught by brand gurus today.
It is hocus. It is marketing snake oil. It’s a fugazi in a blazer.
Building your brand message on a Ouija Board would give you a better chance of getting it right, because at least nobody would pretend the Ouija Board came with an academic lineage and a workshop deck.
New Age Mysticism for Brands
The theory and practice of Brand Archetypes, however polished and well-developed and beautifully packaged it is, is literally new age mysticism for brands. It invites executives and consultants to treat symbolic resonance as if it were commercial leverage. It replaces the hard disciplines of market strategy with an imaginative exercise in self-description. It tells brands to ask, in effect, not “What precise problem do we solve better than viable competitors, and how do we prove it in a way that motivates switching?” but instead, “What kind of mythological character are we?”
Think about how insane that is.
If your company were incorporated on April 15, for example, would its astrological sign be Aries? Would it be, like a true Aries personality is said to be, a confident leader with a cheerful disposition and relentless determination? Or maybe it is on the Aries-Taurus cusp, so it is a real firecracker, a major force to be reckoned with? Would your investors feel reassured if your quarterly strategy review included a serious debate over whether the brand is really more of a Sagittarius than a Capricorn?
Wagering your brand’s entire marketing and communication and advertising strategy on picking one of 12 Brand Archetypes makes even less sense than basing your marketing strategy on the zodiac sign of the date your business was incorporated, or your favorite color. Mine is red, by the way.
And Why Are There Only 12?
Why are there only 12 Brand Archetypes to choose from? Why not 34? Why not 19? Actually, there’s an answer. Ready?
- How many “days of Christmas” are there? 12.
- How many Apostles did Jesus have? 12.
- How many astrological signs are there? 12.
- How many products are sold by the dozen? Thousands.
- There were 12 Olympian gods on the Ancient Greek pantheon.
- Hercules had to perform 12 labors.
- There were 12 Tribes of Israel.
- Eastern Orthodoxy celebrates 12 Great Feasts.
- Hindu’s Lord Shiva has 12 Lingas.
- The chief Norse god, Odin, had 12 sons.
- There are typically 12 jurors in a jury trial, originating from the goddess Athena who summoned 12 citizens to sit in judgement in the play Eumenides.
- There are 12 lunar months.
- King Arthur had 12 knights of the Round Table.
- There are 12 inches in a foot.
I could keep going, but you get the point.
“12” is a quasi-arbitrary and representational number that shows up in a multitude of mythological, historical, and religious references, and it actually makes a lot of sense when you think about things like months, growing seasons, harvests, planetary rotations, tidal shifts, and menstrual cycles. Cycles of 12 make perfect sense in civilization.
Just not in any science related to marketing.
Any research methodology or process based on picking the right one out of a limited choice of only 12 options has no more credibility for brand marketing than deciding that wearing sapphires brings you wisdom, or that your brand is really a Virgo, not an Aries. It is cosmic symbolism sold as commercial strategy, and the fact that the framework just happens to arrive at 12 should, by itself, tell any serious marketer that the number is doing more cultural work than analytical work.
And here is the real kicker.
I am categorically NOT saying that the 12 Brand Archetypes have zero value; of course they have some. They describe 12 different types of brand personalities. BUT NOT TO ALL.
And certainly, it is patently insane to believe that all brands need to (or even can) fit into one of the “official” 12.
Further, you absolutely, definitely, positively do NOT want your brand to have multiple personality disorder, so playing inside of two or three or more Brand Archetypes at once is just, well, insanity. Schizophrenic brands, with one personality for one target market and a different personality for another target market, are confusing. Their marketing messages are diluted and fuzzy, and hundreds of billions of dollars of research and testing by the world’s largest and most successful CPG and enterprise brands and agencies have proven this over more than 75 years.
Where Archetypes Actually Go Wrong
(All Six Places)
So once you strip away the cognitive biases and the mythological window dressing, you are left with the real question. Why do Brand Archetypes fail as a strategic framework?
They fail for six specific reasons, and each one is fatal if your actual goal is customer acquisition rather than a beautifully bound workshop deliverable.
1. Archetypes are inside-out, not outside-in. Archetype work almost always starts with self-description. Who are we? What is our voice? What is our mythological role? This is comforting for internal teams because it feels like identity work. But consumers are not sitting around waiting to understand your inner symbolic truth. They are trying to solve problems, avoid mistakes, reduce risk, save time, make money, and justify their choices. Strategy must begin with the market, not with the mirror.
2. Archetypes flatten multi-dimensional brands into cartoon characters. The strongest brands in the world are not uni-dimensional. They are layered, situational, and context dependent. Category-leading and category-disrupting brands may take a singular marketing focus where appropriate, but they are extremely nuanced in execution. Archetypes tempt marketers to imprison living commercial entities in a static theatrical roles, which is patently absurd.
3. Archetypes are weak on competitor and competition (and yes, they are different), and this is the single biggest failure. Archetypes are essentially silent on the competitive structure of the category. They do not force the strategist to examine incumbent loyalty, switching friction, claim parity, buyer inertia, price ladders, channel constraints, or the reasons competitors continue to win. A framework that does not contemplate the competitive field is not a strategic framework. It is a creative prompt dressed up in mythology. And they don’t (and can’t) effectuate De-Positioning or displacement of competitors or unbinding of their customers.
4. Archetypes confuse coherence with effectiveness. A brand can be beautifully coherent and commercially irrelevant at the same time. I have seen exquisitely designed, perfectly archetyped brands fail because no one could clearly answer why a rational buyer should choose them instead of the alternatives. Consistency is admirable. It is not sufficient. A charming loser is still a loser.
5. Archetypes create false confidence. Because they are easy to teach and easy to repeat, they create an illusion of mastery. Teams begin to believe they have achieved strategic clarity when all they have actually done is pick a narrative costume. False clarity is worse than admitted uncertainty, because it blocks better diagnosis.
6. Archetypes lead to category mimicry dressed up as differentiation. Once every brand in a category starts archetyping, they begin clustering around the same symbolic positions. Everyone’s a Sage. Everyone’s a Hero. Everyone’s a Rebel. The result is a graveyard of sameness pretending to be distinction. You do not escape a competitive market dynamic by picking one of the same 12 costumes your competitors are also wearing.
The Behavioral Science Archetypes Ignore
Here is what really matters, and what every Brand Archetype evangelist somehow manages to never address. Most buying behavior is not a quest for mythic alignment. It is a negotiation with friction, risk, habit, and perception. It is a psychological battle against inertia and incumbency.
Samuelson and Zeckhauser’s work on status quo bias demonstrated that people disproportionately stick with current states or established options, even when switching would objectively improve their situation.
Kahneman, Knetsch, and Thaler linked this directly to loss aversion, showing that people weigh potential losses roughly twice as heavily as comparable expected or projected gains.
Translate this into marketing terms, and the implication is enormous. A challenger brand is not merely trying to sound appealing. It is trying to overcome a psychological tax on change.
Your target consumer is not asking, “Which archetype does this brand embody?” They are asking, often unconsciously, “What might I lose if I switch? What if I make a mistake? What if my current option is good enough? What if I look foolish for changing?”
Archetypes do essentially nothing to address any of that. They do not answer perceived sacrifice. They do not establish superior proof. They do not dismantle incumbent legitimacy. They do not weaponize dissatisfaction with the existing option. They do not expose hidden weaknesses of the category leader. They do not supply an acquisition mechanism at all.
In my book I call this the binding problem. Your target audience is psychologically and behaviorally bound to something, a competitor, a habit, a category default, a settled assumption. Until you disengage that bond, no amount of beautifully archetyped messaging is going to move them. And you cannot acquire a target who is not available to be acquired. Brand Archetypes are blind to the binding problem. They pretend it doesn’t exist. They operate as if your buyer were a blank slate just waiting to be charmed by your symbolic personality and your unbelievable benefits.
Your buyer is not a blank slate. Your buyer is bound.
And until you De-Position whatever your buyer is currently bound to, your archetype is window dressing on a door that was never going to open.
The Harley-Davidson Mirage
People love to invoke Harley-Davidson as living proof that Brand Archetypes work. Harley is The Outlaw. End of case. Marty, you’re wrong. Marty, shut up.
Except Marty is not wrong, and this is exactly the kind of surface-level reading that gets marketers in serious trouble.
Yes, Harley-Davidson has long benefited from associations with rebellion, freedom, independence, and anti-establishment symbolism. That observation is not wrong. It is simply incomplete. And being incomplete is how sacred cows stay sacred.
Over the past few decades, the Harley brand has also evolved (as maturing brands should) well beyond the Outlaw persona of rebellion, gangs, and Hells Angels imagery. The brand has accrued meaning around community, belonging, ritual, craftsmanship, heritage, identity signaling, shared experience, and escape. The Harley rider is not just a lone wolf breaking rules on an empty road. He or she is often part of a tribe, a network, a culture, and a ritualized brand community.
Muniz and O’Guinn’s landmark research on brand community actually used Harley owners as a primary case study to show how brand relationships can generate structured social bonds, rituals, moral responsibility, and shared consciousness among members.
Those behaviors are the psychological opposite of what “Outlaw” is supposed to signify. Harley has successfully distanced itself from the pure outlaw image and now owns a space built from experiential and symbolic benefits like exploration, camaraderie, escape from stress, freedom, community, and brotherhood.
So which is Harley-Davidson? The Outlaw? The Everyman? The Explorer? The answer, inconveniently for the archetype industry, is all of them and none of them. Harley is a multi-dimensional, evolving, layered, strategically sophisticated brand that cannot be compressed into one mythological costume without either reducing reality or contradicting itself.
This is the recurring failure of archetype branding. Once you look closely at genuinely successful brands, you discover they are too rich, too contingent, and too strategically layered to fit cleanly into the mythology. The archetype appears to explain the brand only because the observer selectively notices confirming evidence and conveniently ignores everything that does not fit. That is not strategy. That is confirmation bias with a laminated poster.
And for those who know, ML&R.
The point is that JUST LIKE PEOPLE, brands are multi-dimensional and highly nuanced, and THAT is what makes them real and relatable. The problem is that being real and relatable isn’t enough to drive sales or achieve competitive advantage.
Standing on one primary personality trait narrows your audience instead of expanding it. Uh-oh. I just hinted at yet another sacred marketing cow I am going to grill extra well done: “niching down,” probably one of my favorite pieces of marketing trash. Yes, I said it. And I can prove it. But alas, that is for another article.
Where Archetypes Have a (Very Small) Place
Lazy criticism is just as useless as lazy strategy, so let me be precise. I am not saying Brand Archetypes are useless in every possible circumstance.
They can be mildly useful as an exploratory prompt in the earliest stages of internal brainstorming. They can help non-strategists warm up to a conversation about tone and voice. They can occasionally surface an adjective, a metaphor, or a visual cue that becomes creatively helpful three or four steps later in the process.
That is where archetypes belong. Downstream. Secondary. Subordinate. Tightly controlled. They are rough prompts. They are not strategy. They are not market diagnosis. They are not Positioning. They are not a replacement for competitive analysis, buyer insight, segmentation discipline, proof structure, or De-Positioning logic. They are the brainstorming equivalent of doodling on a napkin, and that napkin should never make it into the final deck.
The second an archetype moves from a light exploratory provocation to the central organizing principle of the brand, the team is in trouble. That is the point where strategic work has been quietly outsourced to a mythology kit, and the team just does not know it yet.
Even the serious academic literature that studies brand personality does not support the bloated strategic claims made by the archetype industry. Kevin Lane Keller’s foundational work on customer-based brand equity makes clear that the power of a brand lives in what consumers have learned, seen, felt, and remembered about it, and how that knowledge shapes response.
Jennifer Aaker’s influential work on brand personality identified dimensions that can be associated with brands, but she never claimed her framework was a substitute for the actual architecture of competitive advantage.
Later academic work by Geuens, Weijters, and De Wulf went further and revised brand personality measurement entirely, because earlier approaches were capturing more than personality alone and behaving unstably in the field.
In plain English: even the academics who study brand personality wouldn’t sign off on what the Brand Archetype industry is selling on a Tuesday.
What Actually Works
If you want to build a brand that can actually win, start where serious strategy always has to start. Start with the market, the target, the problem, the competitive frame, and the perceptual obstacles standing between your brand and the conversion you need.
What you need is not a mythological personality profile. What you need is a real Brand Positioning Platform. And a real Brand Positioning Platform is built from what I call the Four Essential Elements.
Element 1: A meaningful benefit statement. A short, specific statement describing your specific target customer and the specific pain point, problem, or desire that your proposition promises to fix, solve, or fulfill. Not vaguely. Not poetically. Precisely.
Element 2: The element of provability. A reason for your target customer to actually believe your meaningful benefit statement is legit and relevant to their needs and desires. A promise without a reason to believe is advertising vapor. Keller’s customer-based brand equity research makes exactly this point, and you will notice that nowhere in his framework does anyone need to lock their brand into a mythic persona template.
Element 3: A dimension of differentiation, not “difference.” How your brand, product, or service creates an entirely new playing field, not just a “better mousetrap” comparison with your competitors. Difference is everywhere in every category. Differentiation is rare, and it is what changes the perceived standard of comparison.
Element 4: A De-Positioning component. Inarguably the single most important element of all, and the piece the archetype evangelists never, ever touch. De-Positioning is the reason why your target consumers should NOT consider your competitors as viable options to solve their problems or fulfill their desires. It is the force that disengages your target customers from whatever brand, habit, or category default they are currently bound to. It is the most important element in customer and client acquisition, and I have devoted an entire book to it.
When these four elements are properly created and woven into what is called a BRAND POSITIONING PLATFORM, then, and ONLY THEN, does a brand have the foundation for creating a multichannel marketing and communications program that turns your brand into a true category leader.
Because you don’t build your brand. Your customers do.
But this only works if you create, message, and come to own your Brand Positioning, and convincingly and compellingly control how your target consumers perceive that ONLY your brand, product, or service can solve their problem or pain point, or fulfill their needs or desires, and that your competitors can’t, won’t, or don’t.
Marty’s Take-Away
Brand Archetypes endure because they are easy to sell, easy to teach, easy to remember, and easy to mistake for wisdom. They flatter the strategist, reassure the client, decorate the workshop, and photograph beautifully for the case study. But markets are unimpressed by decorative strategy. Markets reward advantage.
The serious work of brand building is harder and a lot less glamorous. It requires defining the target with precision, understanding the category’s economics and buyer psychology, uncovering the actual tensions inside the buying decision, framing a meaningful and credible promise, proving that promise in ways the target can easily validate, creating real differentiation that changes the frame of comparison, and then building a De-Positioning platform powerful enough to break the psychological binding between your target and whatever they are currently using or tolerating.
That is the work. That is the discipline. That is strategy.
Brand Archetypes do none of this. They perform strategy at best. They do not execute it.
I will leave you with these last two thoughts.
You must think of brands as you would think of powerful and successful people. While they may have a “primary” characteristic or personality trait that seems to overpower any others, no one, and no brand, is a single-dimensional entity. You definitely are not. Your favorite products are not either. And the brands you love the most are the ones that refuse to reduce themselves to a single mythological costume.
And lastly, consumers really don’t care at all what YOU think your brand is, or what YOU think it means, or what YOU say it stands for. They only care about what it does for them. We all wish it were otherwise. It isn’t.
And if your brand really truly does solve their needs better than your competitors can, they won’t care if your brand personality is that of Mother Teresa or Genghis Khan.
So go ahead. Ask Zoltar. Pick an archetype. Light the incense. Chant. Build the deck. Admire the mood board. Print the posters. Then, when your sales flatline, your customer acquisition costs climb, and your target market keeps buying from the same competitors they trusted yesterday, you can begin the actual work you should have done in the first place.
Positioning. Provability. Differentiation. De-Positioning. Competitive advantage.
In other words, strategy.
Selected Sources & Citations
Kahneman, Daniel. Thinking, Fast and Slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2011. See also Nobel Prize biographical and lecture materials on judgment under uncertainty, NobelPrize.org, 2002.
Samuelson, William, and Richard Zeckhauser. “Status Quo Bias in Decision Making.” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 1, no. 1 (1988): 7–59.
Mark, Margaret, and Carol S. Pearson. The Hero and the Outlaw: Building Extraordinary Brands Through the Power of Archetypes. McGraw-Hill, 2001.
Jung, C. G. The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious. Collected Works of C. G. Jung, Vol. 9, Part 1. Princeton University Press edition, 1954.
Kahneman, Daniel, Jack L. Knetsch, and Richard H. Thaler. “Anomalies: The Endowment Effect, Loss Aversion, and Status Quo Bias.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 5, no. 1 (1991): 193–206.
Muniz, Albert M., Jr., and Thomas C. O’Guinn. “Brand Community.” Journal of Consumer Research 27, no. 4 (2001): 412–432.
Keller, Kevin Lane. “Conceptualizing, Measuring, and Managing Customer-Based Brand Equity.” Journal of Marketing 57, no. 1 (1993): 1–22.
Aaker, Jennifer L. “Dimensions of Brand Personality.” Journal of Marketing Research 34, no. 3 (1997): 347–356.
Geuens, Maggie, Bert Weijters, and Kristof De Wulf. “A New Measure of Brand Personality.” International Journal of Research in Marketing 26, no. 2 (2009): 97–107.
