EVOLVING LADDERS

EVOLVING-LADDERS-IMAGE

This is an incisive take on Positioning and memory science, written by Brain Scientist and Brand Strategist Rande Vick, exclusively for Master Positioning. For other insightful articles and perspectives, follow Rande on LinkedIn here.

The Metaphor That Used To Feel Right

Brands have spent 45 years trying to climb a ladder. Turns out the rungs were fluid.

In his memoir Back Story, British comedian David Mitchell wrote about a childhood memory that stuck with him for years. There he is, standing in an open field, watching a massive bird of prey swoop down to land close enough that he feels the wind off its wings. He remembered the feeling of awe, the landscape, and the exact moment with vivid recollection.

Years later, a conversation with his parents would challenge his thinking. They reminded him about the time they went to a falconry display. Young David was sitting in the audience, at a safe distance. It was his dad who actually put on the thick leather glove and let the huge falcon land on his arm. The younger Mitchell could have sworn it was his own arm!

You should know that David wasn’t lying. His brain had just edited the memory over the years. Somewhere along the line, the fact that he was just a spectator that day was edited out, and he imagined himself as the center of the story. He spent years telling that story, which further cemented the memory.

Ever lose your keys, though you could swear you remember where you left them?

That’s not a glitch. That’s just how memory works.

Memory and imagination are like peanut butter and chocolate, as it turns out.

The hippocampus, default mode network, and a bunch of prefrontal areas don’t much care whether you’re replaying what happened yesterday or inventing next Tuesday.

What does all this have to do with marketing you ask? Let’s get to it.

In their prolific book, Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind (1981), Al Ries and Jack Trout handed strategists a seemingly apt metaphor: the ladder in the mind. Every category has a ladder. And of course, every ladder has rungs. The top rung? These are the brands everyone think of first. You know, like Hertz, Coke, Apple or Kleenex. Everyone else either fights their way up the ladder, or tries to build a brand new one. That metaphor used to feel right.

But then we learned more about the way our brains actually work… Functional MRI machines didn’t exist in 1981. If they had, Ries and Trout wouldn’t have called it a ladder. They mapped market behavior brilliantly, but in the early 80’s they just didn’t have the tools to look under the hood of the human brain to study the mechanics.

They worked off the assumption that memories get recorded once, filed away, and pulled out intact. A lot of people still think this is how memory works today… like some sort of video file saved on a hard drive.

But memory science debunked this idea years ago. Memory isn’t a file cabinet, recorded video, or a runged ladder. It’s a bit more like opening iMovie or CapCut – ready to dice and splice up images, stories and whatever you “see” at recall.

So then, when someone thinks of a category, that existing memory goes soft. And for a brief window, new information, context, or something with emotional weight gets embedded before the memory sets again. Voila, memory edit.

Get Marty’s newest articles emailed to you as soon as they are published.

But the brain doesn’t even bother to open that edit window unless it’s hit with a strong dose of novelty.

If there’s no real surprise, the “lazy” brain skips the effort.

If there is a surprise, the brain opens the door to let the new information in.

This means position isn’t like real estate that you buy once and fence off. It’s a living memory that has the potential to be edited whenever someone triggers the category.

You don’t own a permanent rung; you show up to win the edit.

This doesn’t mean we throw out everything we’ve learned from those trailblazers. But we should evolve it. Old-school repetition tries to hammer your brand into people’s heads. A reconsolidated memory lens focuses on rewiring how they see the whole category.

When that edit window opens, there are three variables that decide whether your brand updates the category script or gets tossed out:

First is Pattern Mismatch.

When you sound like everyone else, the brain treats you like background noise. Boring. If your positioning just echoes the usual category language, nothing really changes. Your job is to build in a clear, intentional “that’s not what I expected” moment that makes people lift their head and actually rethink the category for a second.

Second is High Emotional Arousal.

The brain saves what it feels. Surprise, excitement, deep trust, righteous anger, pride… those are the signals that say, “keep this version of the story.” Nods and polite agreement don’t rewrite anything; it has to feel like a gut punch from a heavyweight.

Third is Concrete Specificity.

Those jargony words us marketers love… you know, like “disruptive,” “innovative,” or “customer‑centric” – they don’t give the mind of a founder anything to hold onto, so his brain defaults back to the old picture. But specific, tangible claims and cues (i.e. things you can see, feel, or repeat) give the brain actual handles to grab when it updates the story.

Looking at positioning this way also explains a few things the old ladder model never quite could.

Think about “Brand Drift.” Category leaders rarely get knocked down by one brutal onslaught. But they might fade because they turn predictable, allowing a more agile challenger who understands how to edit the category definition around them.

It should also challenge how we think about repetition. Just saying the same thing, the same way, over and over doesn’t necessarily make you memorable, in fact it often will cause the brain to tune our (“heard this before”). Modern positioning is about repeating the core idea with fresh angles and context, so you keep reopening that edit window and staying in sync with how your customer’s life is actually shifting.

That’s what real category dominance looks like. The leaders aren’t just names at the top of a mental list; they’re the ones setting the rules everyone else gets measured against. They become the story the brain uses to make sense of the whole category.

Get Marty’s newest articles emailed to you as soon as they are published.

Look at how this functions in a mature, crowded market like musical instruments. Walk into a trade show or full range music store, and you’ll run into walls of high-spec instruments using identical marketing scripts. Most of it turns into background noise instantly.

Fender’s Custom Shop takes brand-new, top-tier instruments and deliberately beats the snot out of them: worn lacquer, oxidized hardware, synthetic wear marks and “dirty” necks.

On paper, charging extra for a beat-up guitar sounds absurd.

In execution, it is precise memory engineering.

A new instrument carrying fifty years of road wear creates an immediate cognitive speed bump (the mismatch). It connects straight to the romance of rock history and stage-tested grit (the arousal). And quality isn’t communicated through a spec sheet; it’s visual, tactile, and distinct the second you pick it up (the specificity).

Every time a player picks up a $5,000 relic’d guitar, the brand updates its standing as the epitome of authentic heritage.

Before running a positioning strategy into the market, run it against cognitive mechanics:

What is the explicit pattern-interrupt? Where does this positioning break default category expectations?

What emotional state does it trigger? Does it rely on passive head-nodding, or does it trigger high-arousal conviction, desire, tension, relief, or pride?

Is the distinction concrete enough to re-encode? Stripping the logo off the messaging, does a specific, unforgettable claim or cue remain?

If you can’t answer those three questions clearly, you’re not hitting the reconsolidation window quite yet. Back to the woodshed!

Ries and Trout nailed the core premise: the battlefield sits inside the mind. They handed us the absolute best blueprint available back in 1981.

We have a sharper model now. Category positioning isn’t fixed. It is dynamic, context-driven, and constantly being re-edited.

Get Marty’s newest articles emailed to you as soon as they are published.

You don’t win a permanent spot on a ladder. You win the current update, then set the stage to win the next one.

The ladder made for a brilliant map for 45 years.

But the territory has evolved.

Read this article at your convenience:

Fast-Track De-Positioning Masterclass – FREE With Book Purchase

To celebrate publication of the First Edition of my book, I’m hosting a live Fast-Track De-Positioning Masterclass to help you apply the framework immediately.

When you purchase the First Edition of my book here (personally signed to you), your seat in the Masterclass is included at no cost.

What this session is

  • 90-minute live intensive implementation session
  • Direct walkthrough of the De-Positioning Matrix®
  • Practical guidance for applying it to your business

What this session is not

  • Not recorded
  • No replays
  • Not a sales webinar – an intensive training Masterclass

Format

Live on Zoom
NEXT MASTERCLASS: TUESDAY, JUNE 23, 2026 AT 8 AM PACIFIC TIME

Masterclass registration without book purchase: $1,250

Included with book purchase: FREE

Full details and registration link are sent by email after book purchase.