Home › Foundations › Positioning › The Positioning Map

Positioning · Method

The Positioning Map

A positioning map shown as a flat glowing magenta XY grid with competitor brand-points plotted across it and one empty quadrant, suspended inside a much larger multi-layered violet lattice extending beyond it in every direction — the 2D map is only one slice of the full positioning structure.

A positioning map is the fastest honest picture of your category you can draw in an afternoon. Two axes, every competitor plotted, the shape of the market at a glance. It’s a good instrument and you should know how to build one. It also cannot tell you what to do next. That isn’t a flaw. It’s the job description.

2
Variables the grid can hold. Two. Then you’re out of room
4
Moves from a blank grid to a plotted, readable map
16
Weighted cells in the Positioning Matrix® — what the grid has no way to hold

A positioning map — also called a perceptual map; the terms mean the same thing — is a two-axis chart plotting the brands in a category against two attributes buyers care about. Price up one side, quality across the bottom. Every competitor lands somewhere according to how customers perceive them, not what’s true. Where they cluster, you see the crowd. Where they don’t, you see the space.

Whose idea is this? Not mine. It descends from Al Ries and Jack Trout’s ladder — their 1981 account of a category as rungs in the consumer’s mind, where the objective is to find an unoccupied one to own. The grid is that idea in two dimensions.

So: how to build one, the template, the examples. Then what happens when someone in the meeting asks the only question that matters. Great. What do we spend?

The method

How to build a positioning map, in four moves

◆

Select your parameters

List every attribute buyers actually weigh — price, speed, safety, status, reliability, service. Not what you find interesting. What moves the decision.

▣

Choose your two axes

Pick two, one vertical and one horizontal. They must be independent of each other, and both must matter to buyers. This is where the exercise is won or lost.

◈

Rate every brand 1–5

Score each competitor on both axes, and score yourself last so you don’t anchor the field to your own flattery. The scores are perceptions, sourced from customers. Not from the room.

✦

Plot it, then read the gaps

Two scores per brand are its coordinates. Drop them on the grid and the category’s shape appears: the cluster, the outliers, the empty quadrant. Reading it is a separate skill from drawing it.

Why marketers build positioning maps

Because a category is too big to hold in your head, and the grid makes it small enough to argue about. That sounds like faint praise. It isn’t — a perceptual map does four things well.

It shows you the crowd. Categories cluster, and never where the room thinks. Plot eight competitors and you’ll find six stacked in the same square inch, all convinced they’re distinctive, all using the same four adjectives.

It locates you honestly. Your position isn’t where your deck says. It’s where customers put you, and the distance between the two is where the budget has been dying.

It reveals the empty space. The headline benefit every article promises, and real up to a point I’ll come back to.

And it makes strategy discussable. Put a grid on the wall with nine dots on it and the conversation gets specific immediately, because people argue about coordinates instead of adjectives.

Four honest jobs. Notice what isn’t on the list.

Choosing your two axes is 80% of the work

Everything else is arithmetic. This part is judgment, and the wrong axes don’t give you a weak chart. They give you a confident one pointing the wrong way. Three tests.

Does it drive choice? Price qualifies. Safety qualifies in car seats and doesn’t in chewing gum. “Innovation” never qualifies, because nobody has stood in an aisle weighing innovation.

Are the two independent? Chart price against value for money and you’ve drawn a diagonal, because the second is mostly a function of the first. If one score predicts the other, you have one axis drawn twice.

Can customers perceive it? An axis buyers can’t see isn’t a perception, it’s a specification. Thread count is measurable; whether anyone experiences it is another matter.

Then the part nobody mentions: run it more than once. Two axes is one slice through a category with fifteen dimensions. Price and quality is one slice; price and service is another, and the leader who dominates the first can sit alone and exposed in the second. Marketers draw one chart, find one gap, and build a business on it. Draw five.

Which is the tell. The instrument’s answer to “we need more than two variables” is draw another one — a tool handing the problem back to you.

The template: build yours this afternoon

No download, no email gate.

1 — Define the category. One sentence: “The set of brands a [buyer] considers when they need [job to be done].” Can’t finish it? You’re not ready to chart. You’re ready to do research.

2 — List candidate parameters. Six to ten attributes buyers weigh. Beside each, write how you know it drives choice. “We think it does” isn’t an answer, and half your list dies here.

3 — Pick two axes. Run the three tests, then write out what a 1 and a 5 mean on each. This is what makes the scores mean anything.

4 — List the consideration set. Ries and Trout put the ceiling around seven brands per ladder; nineteen names means you’re charting an industry, not a decision.

5 — Build the scoring grid. One row per brand, one column per axis, plus a column for the evidence behind each score. That column is the quality-control system: a cell you can’t source is a guess, and by Thursday it’s indistinguishable from data.

6 — Fill it from customers. Survey, interviews, review mining, win/loss notes. Twenty customers beats a focus group, and both beat the room.

Two rules make it worth having. The scores are perceptions: if customers believe the leader is more reliable and your warranty data disagrees, the leader still scores higher. And use one scorer throughout, or your dot alone was measured differently.

7 — Plot and label. Want a third dimension? Size each dot by market share. Note what it cost: your third variable had to be smuggled in as bubble diameter, because the grid had run out of directions.

Three worked examples, and what each one missed

General Motors, 1924. Alfred Sloan drew this chart fifty-seven years before anyone named the technique. Chevrolet was “the working man’s car.” Pontiac, affordable style. Oldsmobile, middle-class success. Buick, professional achievement. Cadillac crowned it: ultimate luxury and status. Price against status, five brands, no rung left to stand on — and many components were shared across divisions. The position did the work, and Ford, still selling reliable transport at low cost, watched GM take half the American car market. The layout gave Sloan the ladder. It never told him what to spend on which division.

Volvo and safety. Volvo owned safety, BMW the ultimate driving machine, Mercedes prestige. A chart shows that cleanly. But look at how the position is built: for families with young children concerned about car safety, Volvo is the safest SUV on the market, because we use more side airbags and steel struts than any other SUV. By naming more airbags than any other SUV, Volvo implies — never states — that other SUVs may be less protective with your kids in the back. That’s an embedded De-Positioning component doing half the work. A positioning map plots Volvo’s dot atop the safety axis. It cannot see the mechanism that put it there.

Hathaway shirts. Ogilvy’s campaign, and the one that should make you suspicious of your own axes. Hathaway shirts were well made and not extraordinary; chart the category on quality and price and Hathaway sits mid-field, a dot among dots. Ogilvy understood men weren’t buying shirts for thread count — they were buying what the shirt said about who they were. Competitors could copy the shirt. They couldn’t copy the position. The axis that won wasn’t on the chart, because it wasn’t a product attribute at all.

Yours is only as good as the perception you put in it

Every article warns that bad data makes a bad chart. True, and useless, because nobody thinks their data is bad.

The problem isn’t that perception data is wrong. It’s that a chart made of guesses looks exactly like a chart made of research. Same clean grid, same confident dots, same authority on the wall. Twenty customer interviews and a Tuesday in a conference room produce identical output, and only one of them knows anything.

Which makes it dangerous rather than merely inaccurate. A rough draft presented as rough is a useful conversation. One that’s been through a design pass into a board deck has become evidence — cited in month three by people who weren’t there in month one, long after anyone remembers the scores were a hunch.

So: source every cell, score from outside the building, mark your confidence. Internal scoring doesn’t produce a slightly optimistic picture. It produces a picture of your ambitions — the thing you were testing.

A map you don’t trust is still useful. One you trust for the wrong reasons costs you a year.

An empty quadrant is not an opportunity

Here’s the promise every article makes: find the white space, go own it. It’s where the instrument does its real damage — because an empty space is not automatically a position worth owning. It may be empty because nobody wants it. A gap can be vacant for four reasons, and the geometry is identical in all four.

The gap is real. Customers want it, nobody serves it, the economics work. What everyone assumes they’re looking at.

Nobody wants it. Cheap and prestigious. High-touch and self-serve. The quadrant is empty because it’s a contradiction in the buyer’s head, and budget doesn’t resolve those.

The economics don’t work. Someone went there. It didn’t pay. The grid has no memory, so the corpse isn’t a dot.

The market isn’t ready. The nastiest one, because you’re right and it doesn’t matter. Google Glass in 2013 was a real attempt to obsolete the smartphone, and the technology worked. But phones still felt adequate, the disadvantage Glass eliminated wasn’t painful enough yet, and the awkwardness of a face computer outweighed the gains. Google was five to ten years early. Every EV before Tesla sat in the same empty quadrant with sixty to a hundred miles of range.

Being right too early is indistinguishable from being wrong.

All four look like white space. The instrument cannot tell them apart, because it plots what is, and every one of those questions is about what would be. The empty quadrant isn’t an answer. It’s a question — why is nobody here? — and the grid has no opinion.

Which is why I’m unromantic about open water. The empty ocean and the one nobody swims in look identical from the beach. The crowded quadrant is where the money is.

The Positioning Matrix® vs the 2D positioning map

Now the sentence this page has been walking toward. A map plots perception. The Positioning Matrix® allocates resource. One describes where you are; the other tells you what to spend.

That’s not a criticism. Expecting otherwise is a category error, committed daily — a team draws the chart, spots a gap, and leaves believing they have a strategy. They have a diagnosis. Nobody wrote the prescription.

A map has two axes. The Matrix® has sixteen weighted cells: four Essential Positioning Elements — Meaningful Benefit, Provable and Easily Evident, Frame of Differentiation, and the De-Positioning Component — across four Marketing Environments. Every cell carries a percentage, and those percentages are budget, time, messaging, creative.

Ask a positioning map how much Meaningful Benefit to fund versus how much Provability. It has no answer. Not a poor one — no mechanism to have one. Ask the Matrix® and you get 40% Meaningful Benefit against 10% Provability when you’re attacking an incumbent, inverting to 20% and 40% when you’re the one attacked. Same brand, different environment, different money.

Then the omission that decides everything. The grid has no De-Positioning axis. It shows the incumbent‘s dot with great precision and offers no mechanism for making them irrelevant — because unbinding a customer isn’t a coordinate, it’s a force, and a grid has nowhere to put a force. In the Matrix®, De-Positioning holds 30% of your resources across the Introductory, Offensive and Defensive environments alike. It’s the constant. Without a De-Positioning element, Positioning always fails.

Which is the deeper point. A chart is the category as it stands, and everything interesting in positioning strategy is about changing it. The map is the state; it has no theory of motion.

The map describes. The Matrix® decides.

The map I actually use plots customers, not brands

You might expect me to finish by telling you to throw the grid away. I won’t, because I run a perceptual map myself. Two axes, four quadrants, the same instrument. Mine plots a different subject, and that’s the whole argument.

The classic positioning map plots brands against attributes. Mine — the Binding States Perceptual Map — plots targets against their switch potential. Vertical axis: motivation to switch, how badly this customer wants out. Horizontal: ability to switch, from free to choose down to trapped by contracts, costs, dependencies.

Two axes intersect. Four quadrants, every one a different strategic reality. High motivation, high ability, upper right: Unbound — nobody has them, so position and go. Low motivation, high ability, bottom right: Loosely Bound — they could leave tomorrow and see no reason to, because their incumbent is good enough. Low motivation, low ability, bottom left: Strongly Bound — loyal, integrated into habit and self-concept, immovable without a trigger event. High motivation, low ability, upper left: Crisis Bound — they want out and can’t. Prisoners. Show them the door and remove the lock.

Watch what it does that the other can’t. It hands you a budget. 50–60% of competitive spend to the Loosely Bound — large segment, reasonable conversion, the primary battlefield. 20–30% to the Crisis Bound, small but converting exceptionally, where the work is barrier removal rather than persuasion. 15–20% to the Unbound: easy wins, tiny segment, over-funded by most teams because the wins feel easy. 0–5% to the Strongly Bound — ignore them, because those resources would convert ten times as many Loosely Bound.

Those are percentages, off a two-axis chart. Which is the point: the problem was never the geometry. Two axes were plenty. The problem was what you chose to plot on them. The Binding States map determines who you target, what you say, how you spend. A price-versus-quality chart determines where the dots go.

Same instrument. One plots the category, one the opportunity.

So build your map. Properly. Then put it down and go find out who’s available. The full De-Positioning Matrix® — four Binding States crossed with four De-Positioning Elements — is in the book.

A map shows you the room. It never tells you who’s ready to leave.

FAQ

Common questions

What is a positioning map?

A two-axis chart plotting the brands in a category against two attributes buyers care about, placed by customer perception rather than by fact. It shows where the category clusters, where you sit, and where the grid is empty.

Is a positioning map the same as a perceptual map?

Yes, interchangeably. “Perceptual map” is the more useful name, because it emphasizes what’s being plotted — perception, not reality — which is what people forget within ten minutes of drawing one.

How do you build a perceptual map?

Four moves. Select the parameters buyers decide on, choose two as your axes, rate every competitor 1–5 from customer data, then plot each at its coordinates and read the clusters and gaps. The data is the hard part.

What axes should I use?

Two attributes that each independently drive choice and that customers can actually perceive. Price and quality is the default pairing and usually the least informative, because it’s the one your competitors already optimized for. The axis worth drawing is the one nobody in your category is measuring on.

What are the limitations of a positioning map?

Four. It holds two variables and no more. It’s only as good as the perception data in it, which is usually internal opinion wearing a lab coat. It shows empty space without saying whether that space is empty for a reason. And it describes your category without allocating a dollar.

Does an empty quadrant mean an opportunity?

Not automatically, and this is the expensive one. A gap can be empty because nobody wants what’s there, because the economics don’t work, or because the market isn’t ready. The geometry is identical in all four cases. Being right too early is indistinguishable from being wrong.

Positioning map vs the Positioning Matrix® — what’s the difference?

One describes, the other allocates. The map plots two variables to show where you sit. The Matrix® runs four Essential Positioning Elements across four Marketing Environments and returns percentages telling you what to fund. Use both, in order. The mistake was never drawing the map. It’s stopping there.

The complete system

Positioning wins attention. De-Positioning wins markets.

Advanced Brand Positioning and The De-Positioning Matrix® book cover

The full system — the four essential elements, the four marketing environments, and how the Positioning Matrix® pairs with the De-Positioning Matrix® to displace competitors — is in the book. Start there, or work with Marty directly.

Fast-Track De-Positioning Masterclass – FREE With Book Purchase

To celebrate publication of the First Edition of my book, I’m hosting a live Fast-Track De-Positioning Masterclass to help you apply the framework immediately.

When you purchase the First Edition of my book here (personally signed to you), your seat in the Masterclass is included at no cost.

What this session is

  • 90-minute live intensive implementation session
  • Direct walkthrough of the De-Positioning Matrix®
  • Practical guidance for applying it to your business

What this session is not

  • Not recorded
  • No replays
  • Not a sales webinar – an intensive training Masterclass

Format

Live on Zoom
NEXT MASTERCLASS: TUESDAY, JUNE 23, 2026 AT 8 AM PACIFIC TIME

Masterclass registration without book purchase: $1,250

Included with book purchase: FREE

Full details and registration link are sent by email after book purchase.